What is a Bitcoin ETP? How It Works, Risks, and Why DeFi Alternatives Are Smarter

Confused between buying Bitcoin on CEX, storing it yourself, or using a Bitcoin ETP (and understanding it)?

However, not all Bitcoin ETPs are created equal.

And depending on how you buy it, through a bank, a broker, or even DeFi, your returns, risks, and even taxes can change drastically.

In this article, you walk through what a Bitcoin ETP actually is, how it compares to holding Bitcoin yourself, what BlackRock’s entry into the market means for you, and why new DeFi-native alternatives (like MCSOL) might quietly be the smartest play on the board.

What is a Bitcoin ETP?

A Bitcoin ETP (Exchange-Traded Product) is a way to invest in Bitcoin without actually owning or managing it yourself.

Instead of setting up wallets, securing private keys, or figuring out how exchanges work, you simply buy a tradable security (aka a stock) that mirrors the price of Bitcoin. It’s listed on a regular stock exchange (like SIX in Switzerland or Nasdaq in the U.S.), and you can purchase it using the same app you use to buy Apple or Tesla shares (or a neo-broker like Revolut or Robinhood).

Some Bitcoin ETPs are physically backed, meaning the issuer holds real Bitcoin for you in a vault. Others are synthetic, meaning they just track the price using contracts. Either way, you don’t touch the Bitcoin; you just see the value move.

“The bitcoin ETFs are spot ETFs which means the organization selling the ETF must secure the funds to back the ETF directly. That makes these IOUs. They’re not promising to pay you bitcoin later, they’re promising to pay you dollars later.” u/chrnk1130

For people who want exposure without the hassle of self-custody or crypto onboarding, this is an easy on-ramp. But as you’ll see later, ease comes with trade-offs, and some of them are bigger than they look.

💡 Interested in understanding more about what ETPs mean in crypto?

How does a Bitcoin ETP work?

At its core, a Bitcoin ETP is a mere financial product designed to mirror Bitcoin’s price, but how it achieves this depends on the structure supporting it.

1. Physically-backed ETPs

These hold real Bitcoin in cold storage.

Example: 21Shares Bitcoin ETP (SIX Swiss Exchange)

Each share you buy represents actual Bitcoin held by a custodian, typically a regulated institution that goes through a strict process: acquiring Bitcoin on behalf of the issuer, storing it in offline cold wallets (often multi-signature and geographically distributed), undergoing regular third-party audits (like those conducted by BDO or KPMG), and providing daily proof of holdings (via public attestations or blockchain-verifiable wallet balances) to ensure that the product’s value is fully backed and transparently maintained.

The Physical Cold Storage Token and Cold Storage Device patents show how embedding private keys in multi-layered physical hardware ensures that Bitcoin backing an ETP remains offline and tamper-resistant (up to 100% air-gapped security, with zero online key exposure during storage).

2. Synthetic ETPs

Synthetic ETPs don’t hold any Bitcoin. Instead, they use financial contracts (e.g., futures, options, or total return swaps) to replicate Bitcoin’s price movements. These instruments are managed by the issuer or affiliated institutions (like investment banks or derivatives desks) and often settled through clearing houses (e.g., ICE Clear, Eurex Clearing) or over-the-counter (OTC) desks (via broker-dealer networks or market makers).

Legal scholar Houman B. Shadab from New York Law School highlights that synthetic Bitcoin derivatives, especially those settled in cash rather than physical delivery, may fall outside the full scope of U.S. commodity regulations, offering issuers regulatory leeway while posing potential transparency and oversight challenges.

While this setup is cheaper and faster to scale, it introduces counterparty risk: if the issuer, broker, or contract provider defaults or becomes insolvent, your position could become unredeemable, regardless of Bitcoin’s actual market performance.

🔍 Unlike synthetic ETPs, MC² Finance’s DeFi-native ETP/ETF eliminates intermediaries. Strategies are executed directly on-chain, giving you 100% price exposure and up to 15%+ real yield, without relying on brokers, clearinghouses, or custodians to stay solvent.

Bitcoin ETPs’ pricing and redemption

Every day, the issuer of the ETP calculates something called the Net Asset Value (NAV) (i.e., the fair value of the Bitcoin backing the product, divided by the number of shares).

This “fair value” or price of Bitcoin is usually sourced from a weighted average of top crypto exchanges. For example, The MVIS Bitcoin Benchmark Rate (MVIBBR), used by many European ETPs like those from VanEck and 21Shares, sources price data from Bitstamp, Coinbase, Gemini, itBit, Kraken, and LMAX Digital.

It calculates a volume-weighted average price (VWAP) with built-in filters (like minimum trade size thresholds, time-weighted price smoothing, and exclusion of data from illiquid intervals) to remove outliers (like sudden price spikes due to thin order books or wash trading) and reduce manipulation (such as spoofing, where large fake orders are placed to mislead the market, or quote stuffing, where excessive orders are submitted to slow down competitors).

If the ETP is physically backed, the issuer must constantly track and report the actual assets in custody and ensure that the number of ETP shares in circulation matches the underlying crypto held (1:1 or according to the defined ratio), with regular audits and transparency reports to reassure investors that the product is fully collateralized and not over-leveraged.

If it’s a synthetic ETP, pricing doesn’t come from holding real Bitcoin; instead, it depends on financial derivatives like futures, options, or swaps. These are traded on secondary markets (like CME, Eurex, or OTC desks), which means the ETP’s price tracks how those instruments move, not the spot price directly. This setup can introduce extra costs, such as spreads (the gap between bid and ask prices), management or swap fees, and slippage (price drift during execution). It may also lag or diverge slightly from actual Bitcoin prices, especially during high volatility or low liquidity periods.

Benefits of buying a Bitcoin ETP

Not everyone wants to wrestle with wallets, seed phrases, or the fear of sending Bitcoin to the wrong address. For many, the biggest value of a Bitcoin ETP is peace of mind: wrapped in a format they already understand.

Here’s what makes it appealing:

1) You don’t need to manage private keys

You hold the ETP in the same brokerage account (like DEGIRO, Interactive Brokers, or Swissquote) you already use (just like a stock or ETF). No hardware wallet or recovery phrases needed.

“…buy the ETF if you don’t want to hold keys. Keeping coins on an exchange is risk of 100% losses overnight and suppresses the price of Bitcoin in many case.” u/JerryLeeDog

2) It’s traded on regulated exchanges

That means investor protections (like segregation of client assets, insurance coverage, and redemption rights), audited issuers (like 21Shares, VanEck, and WisdomTree), and oversight (like regulatory approval from financial authorities such as BaFin in Germany or FINMA in Switzerland) — something the average crypto exchange can’t always guarantee.

“BlackRock is the only one I read the filing on and they proposed to essentially be fully backed by Bitcoin reserves that are audited/regulated.” u/BrotherAmazing

3) Tax reporting is often simpler

In many countries (like Germany, Switzerland, and the UK), holding a Bitcoin ETP through a stockbroker fits into existing capital gains frameworks. You may even be eligible for tax deferral (up to 100% in tax-advantaged accounts like pensions or ISAs) or reduced tax rates (as low as 0% if held for over a year in jurisdictions like Germany) compared to direct crypto holdings.

“Some BTC ETFs are nice as they can be tax free.” u/Electrical_Invite552

4) Retirement account eligibility

Some Bitcoin ETPs, like those from 21Shares, WisdomTree, and Purpose Investments, qualify for tax-advantaged accounts like IRAs (Individual Retirement Accounts, where gains can grow tax-deferred or tax-free, depending on the account type), pensions (like in Switzerland or Germany, where contributions may be tax-deductible and gains grow tax-deferred), or SIPPs (Self-Invested Personal Pensions in the UK, offering up to 45% tax relief on contributions and tax-free growth within the account).

“With ETF I can legally and easily buy BTC with my retirement account. One click reporting. Perfect? no. Easy and accessible? yes.” u/Frequent_Staff2896

Risks of Bitcoin ETPs

Bitcoin ETPs offer convenience, but like any financial product, they come with trade-offs:

Counterparty risk (the hidden middlemen)

When you buy a Bitcoin ETP, you’re not holding the asset. You’re trusting someone else (aka the issuer and their custodian)  to hold it for you and deliver its value (which they are liable for through a legal obligation called a redemption right to redeem the ETP at its Net Asset Value

If that chain breaks — and yes, it has happened before (e.g., the collapse of FTX and the fallout from Voyager and Celsius, where poor custody or issuer risk management led to user fund losses) — your investment could evaporate.

That’s why some investors are moving toward DeFi-native ETFs/ETPs, like those being developed by MC² Finance, which eliminate this risk entirely. Assets are stored and managed by smart contracts, transparently and on-chain.

Fees, tracking errors & limited control

You don’t see it on the surface, but most ETPs come with hidden friction:

i) Management fees eat into returns, even when the market is flat (ranging from 0.95% [Bitwise Bitcoin Fund] to 1.5% annually [Grayscale Bitcoin Trust], depending on the issuer)

ii) Tracking errors can cause the ETP’s price to drift from actual BTC value (up to 1–3% during volatile periods, especially if liquidity or arbitrage lags)

iii) Redemption limits (like only allowing large institutional redemptions or minimum lot sizes) and market hours (like 9:00–17:30 CET on Xetra or SIX Swiss Exchange) restrict when and how you can trade (unlike Bitcoin, which runs 24/7)

But if you're looking for transparency, around-the-clock flexibility, and a way to actually earn yield on your Bitcoin exposure — traditional ETPs may start to feel like yesterday’s solution.

What is the difference between a Bitcoin ETP and a Bitcoin ETF? (and does BlackRock’s entry changes things)

Both are traded on stock exchanges and track Bitcoin’s price, but the difference lies in structure and location:

a) ETFs (like in the U.S.): Regulated funds that hold real Bitcoin. You own a slice of actual BTC, not a contract.

b) ETPs (common in Europe): A broader group, including ETFs, ETNs, and ETCs. Some hold Bitcoin, some are just debt promises.‍

Bottom line: If you're in the U.S., you're likely buying an ETF. In Europe, it's probably an ETP; same goal, different wrapper.

👉 Want to read more about ETF vs ETP?

How BlackRock’s Bitcoin ETP launch impacts Europe?

So when the world’s largest asset manager, BlackRock, enters the Bitcoin ETP game, it’s a signal, and in Europe, that signal is loud.

1. Legitimacy for the “traditional crowd”

For conservative investors (family offices, pensions, or even everyday savers), crypto still feels foreign. BlackRock’s arrival changes that.

It says:

“This is no longer a fringe asset. It’s on the menu, and it’s being served by the biggest kitchen in finance.”

That kind of endorsement reduces hesitation. It reassures people who’ve been sitting on the sidelines (millions globally, including risk-averse portfolios and regulated funds that couldn’t previously get exposure). And in Europe, where regulatory caution is the norm, this kind of legitimacy matters (because regulatory clarity and institutional endorsements are prerequisites for wide adoption in many EU jurisdictions).

2. A shift in liquidity

Institutional capital tends to follow infrastructure, not ideology.

With BlackRock offering a compliant, easy-to-access Bitcoin product, capital that might have explored DeFi or direct BTC exposure could now flow into regulated ETPs.

That’s both an opportunity and a challenge:

a) Good for visibility and growth (because it legitimizes Bitcoin on traditional platforms and brings billions in managed assets into play)

b) But potentially pulls liquidity away from open, decentralized protocols (which can hurt innovation and yield in DeFi, though it may force these protocols to become more competitive and user-centric)

Platforms will need to compete by offering more than just access, like yield, control, and transparency.

3. Pressure on European regulators

BlackRock’s launch puts pressure on EU regulators to get more consistent in how crypto ETPs are structured and treated, both legally and for taxation purposes.

So far, Europe has a patchwork of ETP wrappers (ETFs, ETNs, ETCs) and a range of tax treatments (e.g., tax deferrals in Germany vs. immediate gains in others) and investor protections (some countries allow retail access, others limit it to professionals). But with major U.S. firms entering the space, harmonization is no longer optional.

Expect to see faster movement on:

i) Standardizing crypto ETP frameworks (e.g., one unified definition of “physically backed” across all EU states)

ii) Clarifying what “backed by Bitcoin” actually means (some issuers use derivatives or claim indirect backing, confusing investors)

iii) Protecting retail investors entering through neo-brokers (e.g., requiring full transparency on custody, fees, and risks)

4. Changing user behavior

This is also a distribution story (because most new investors don’t go to Coinbase or Binance; they use apps they already trust).

BlackRock knows this. That’s why their product is designed for the same apps you use to buy your stocks on.

And when Bitcoin becomes one tap away, with no seed phrase, no bridge, no DEX, it changes the entry point for the next wave of users (expected to be mainstream retail investors, millennials saving for retirement, and even institutional allocators using brokerage apps).

Note: Convenience often comes with trade-offs, and that’s where DeFi-native platforms have to show not just access, but advantages.

Comparing traditional Bitcoin ETPs to DeFi ETPs (like MC² Finance)

Not all Bitcoin ETPs are built the same, and the differences aren’t cosmetic.

The table below breaks it all down 👇

So what does this mean for you?

With a traditional ETP, you’re essentially renting exposure to Bitcoin, and trusting third parties to get the details right. You don't see what’s happening behind the scenes, and your capital isn’t doing much beyond tracking price.

With a DeFi-native ETF/ETP, like those MC² Finance is building, your assets are deployed in real time through programmable strategies (lending, staking, or liquidity provisioning), while staying in your custody, and fully visible on-chain.

Don’t just own crypto, make it work for you.

FAQs

Is a Bitcoin ETP safe?

It’s safer on paper than storing Bitcoin on an unregulated exchange, because it’s tied to traditional financial infrastructure (aka regulated issuers, custodians, and brokers). But it’s not risk-free. If the issuer or custodian fails, your exposure could vanish. That’s why alternatives like DeFi-native ETPs (e.g., MCSOL) are gaining interest.

Should I invest in a Bitcoin ETP or buy Bitcoin directly?

It depends on what matters more to you: control or convenience. Buying Bitcoin directly gives you full control, you hold it, move it, and use it however you want. But it also means you’re responsible for security, wallets, and taxes. ETPs remove those headaches, making it easier to gain exposure (especially in retirement accounts or via stock apps), but you sacrifice autonomy.

💡 Read more about how crypto ETFs work here.

Do Bitcoin ETPs make money?

Most don’t generate income. They simply mirror Bitcoin’s price, so if Bitcoin rises, your ETP’s value rises too. A few structured products might offer yield (like MC² Finance ETP/ETF), especially emerging ones built in DeFi, but these are rare in traditional markets. So your profit comes down to Bitcoin’s price performance and how much the product charges in fees.

What happens if the company behind an ETP fails?

If the issuer collapses or the custodian mishandles the underlying Bitcoin, you could lose some or all of your investment,  especially if the product isn’t physically backed. Always check whether there’s real Bitcoin behind the product or if it’s synthetic. In contrast, DeFi products use smart contracts, so there’s no single company to fail, just code you can verify.

‍